AndI think he may have initiated it on occasions, too, that I'm less sure on.. And you write: The physical violence that occurred between them appeared to me to be mutual., You never actually witnessed any physical violence by Mr. Depp or by Ms. Heard, correct?, Didn't fight on island until last day. Depp.) "Question (40:44), "And this is what she reported to you, correct? If she felt disrespected to initiate a fight and her father had beaten her, she was not going to. Heard countersued for $100 million.. And I think he talked about how chaotic it was, how violent it was. "Dr Anderson(01:03:46). She may have asked them to describe their worst fights. Within a couple of days of the Dec 15, 2015 phone call session, Amber goes to see Dr Anderson in-person. Education Laurel Anderson, PhD earned a degree of a Doctor of Philosophy. Thank you! They're confusing, as you've seen or you haven't seen, actually. Her testimony focused on several sets of documents, Emails (such as ones about introductions and appointment arrangements). She says that she thinks Mr Depp meant or thinks Mr. Depp instigated some of the violence etc. (Name-calling from one party and physical assault from another party could be labelled mutual abuse if the definition gets stretched. And you write: The physical violence that occurred between them appeared to me to be mutual. You never actually witnessed any physical violence by Mr. Depp or by Ms. Heard, correct?Dr Anderson (56:48), And you said that They were each victims of domestic violence, both in their family. And he tried to deescalate far more than I think she did., During her testimony, Dr Andersondescribed Johnny and Amber's relationship as "mutual abuse.". Dr Andersontestifiedthat Amber says she hits Johnny "to keep him there," but from the recording weknow that Johnnyhas a pattern of leaving when Amber gets physical. Taylor and Francis. And I think he talked about how chaotic it was, how violent it was. DrAnderson is a long-time couples' therapist based in Los Angeles. Times given in brackets throughout represent the time on the transcript. Dr. Laurel Rene Anderson-Cowell, MD Allergist Portland, OR In-person visits Book an appointment for free What's your insurance plan? About an inch., So is it fair to say those are small bruises in more than one place? Yes. Always consult a medical provider for diagnosis and treatment. She hits back and now starts it for pride because father hit her.. (See my postPatriarchy Isn't The Only or Main Reason for Partner Abusefor moreon the topic. No discussion of session content during the trial. As I worked my way through Dr Anderson's testimony, I developed more and more questions about the therapy and this post becamemuch more extensive than I anticipated. And Dr Anderson stated that Johnny "tried to deescalate far more than I think she did.(01:02:36), Is Dr Anderson's definition of mutual abuse that there was abusive type behavior from both parties even though it wasn't to equal degrees? Additionally, she offered some impressions of the couple's relationship and behaviors. You were seeing multiple bruises on Amber's face when you were talking about how the size of it your fingers were under your eyes. She started violence. So what did you mean?Dr Anderson (41:39)"That was her asking me. "Question, "And the him whom she threw acan at. Domestic violence against men and boys: Experiences of male victims of intimate partner violence. he only basis you had with respect to the cause of the injuries was what Ms. Heard told you, correct? And so is it your testimony that she showed you photos of her injuries shortly after the alleged event., Somewhere in the period while she still had injuries. And she says that she hits back and now she starts it and sometimes hits him first because her history is having been violated by her father physically and just out of pride, a lot of things trigger her. He got aggressive, threatening, didn't touch him, hid in bathroom. What were you referring to there? After this introduction, Amber corresponds with Dr Anderson about possibly making an appointment. Help Millions of people find the right doctor and care they need, Get immediate care and visit with providers from the comfort of your home, or anywhere, Urgent care centers can be faster and cheaper for situations that are not life threatening, Doctors and patients discuss the latest medical treatments and health tips, Search prescription drugs for why theyre used, side effects and more, Back and Neck Surgery (Except Spinal Fusion). 2-hour recorded conversation between Amber and Johnny, National Domestic Violence Hotline says that mutual abuse is a myth, research supporting the idea that some partner abuse is, Anxiety Worksheets, Books, and Recordings by Ann Silvers, 7 Diet Tips for Mental Health and Wellbeing, 101 Emotion Words List: Expand Your Emotion Vocabulary, Depression in Men: It Happens More Than You Think. Sept 2015 Introduction and Appointment Request. A sound bite that came out of Dr Anderson's testimony is that Johnny is reported to have said "She gave as good as she got.". (The penetrated her with a liquor bottle part may be a new accusation with the US trial. When. Correct? And she says that she hits back and now she starts it and sometimes hits him first because her history is having been violated by her father physically and just out of pride, a lot of things trigger her. excusing her violence as reactionary (32:44) (34:53) (45:57) (52:29)(52:49) (53:42). 4. ", And is the him you're referring to, Johnny Depp?, "Okay, let's move to the next page, please. Domestic violence charges had already been made. There may have been more, but I don't remember., Go back very briefly to exhibit two. InGender Inclusive Treatment of Intimate Partner Abuse: A Comprehensive Approach, John Hamelputs forward "questions to ponder in assessing mutuality: How repetitive or excessive are the physical assaults? May 27, 2016: When Johnny did not agree to her financial demands, she filed for an emergency ex-parte Request for Restraining Order even though he is not in the state and will not be back for an extended period of time. It was a point of pride to her. ", This is stunning given that earlier in the same phone session Amber stated that she hit Johnny "as he sat there talking incoherently. But at no point in any of Dr Anderson's testimony does Johnny say that he was physically violent with Amber. The probability that DV wasn't discussed in joint sessions other than the one squashed mention of it in the first session is supported by this testimony: "When we were going through Amber's, the incidents where Amber described Mr. Depp being violent, Mr. Depp was not present. Search doctors, conditions, or procedures . Dr. Laurel Anderson , PHD . I think there's other data that will support this. I know she came in in person to show me. What I said previously, and I'll say it again, he's kind of doing a retrospective of trying to understand a relationship and is characterizing it as chaotic and violent. The DV community's rejection of the idea of mutual abuse is grounded in their belief that DV is caused by patriarchy. No closed fist. May 24, 2016: Shehad her lawyer send Johnny's lawyer a letter threatening to go public with accusations of DV unless he agreed to a lucrative financial divorce settlement. And I just want to focus on the one snippet on base, page three. Dr. Laurel Anderson has 15 years of experience in clinical psychology. (I talk more about this in another post:Why is it So Hard To Recognize Abuse OF Men BY Women as a Problem?). And so she was reporting on that.Question (45:57), Then you write: He got aggressive, threatening, didn't touch him, hid in bathroom. What were you referring to there?Dr Anderson (46:09), What she reported to me, which was an improvement that she didn't participate.Question (46:22), So is it fair to say that she told you she did not hit him at that time?, Yes, that's what I believe my notes say. How frequent and severe is the nonphysical abuse?". Her testimony was presented as a video deposition. "Question (40:34), "Did she tell you that he had hit her first, or was she the one who initiated the slap? She had rapid fire talking., I pointed out the process to her at some point, and she got it thatno one could actually have a decent dialogue with her if she was rapid firing and talking over and just barraging. Dr. Laurel Anderson, a clinical psychologist based in Los. He hits her. Dr. Anderson failed both her patients, but actively harmed JD by characterizing their relationship as . Two things. 310-206-6232. Get contact info, maps, medical practice history, affiliated hospitals & more. Click here for the video recording of Dr Anderson's Johnny v Amber Day 3 defamation trial testimony. I think while he's talking, and I'm not trying to be obtrusive with my taking notes. You write: Didn't fight on island until last day. It has typically been the case that one member of the couple is motivated to keep embarrassing information from being talked about.). What is Dr. Laurel Anderson, PHD's office address? Huge fight. Was chaotic violence, but gave as good as she got.. She reported trying to initiate a fight with him one night by slapping him when she was offended by what he said.", Then in the last sentence: It was also at this time that she showed me photos of her injuries. When did Miss Heard show you photos of her alleged injuries?, Well, to the best of my pulling together the information I wrote down, I'm saying it was right after that fight. I'm listening. If she felt disrespected". Dr Anderson is a long-time couples' therapist based in Los Angeles. She showed me photos, but she also came in and showed me in person., Other than the bruising on her face, what other injuries did she show you?, I don't remember. Her current practice location address is 9911 W Pico Blvd . And my recollection is she came in --- she talked to me by phone, and then came in the next day. They don't say a lot. "And at that point, because I'm typing quickly as they go along, I'm switching into a different voice more about the process between them, where she has, I believe, interrupted him. Find a doctor near you. And again, that entry is from a session where Mr. Depp was not physically present, correct? [Note: There is nothing to indicate that Amber was threatened by Johnny physically, but Dr Anderson may have concluded that Amber felt threatened that Johnny would leave her because of the accusation of her having an affair with another woman. And when left alone to speak, he can describe intelligently what's going on. People Also Viewed Frequently Asked Questions about Anderson Laurel, PhD How is Anderson Laurel, PhD rated? Dr. Anderson says Heard and Depp did not visit together on their first session. Laurel B. Yates, MD, MPH. . NPI details are as mentioned below. No closed fist. Im so glad to hear that you are enjoying my posts about the Depp/Heard case. I don't agree with the idea that partner abuse is causedsolely or even mostly because of patriarchy. Im wondering if Dr. Anderson knew about the apparent diagnosis or diagnosed it herself during the time she worked with Ms. Heard, because if either of that is the case Im left wondering why she believed Ms. Heards versions without seemingly double checking? His mother is dead at this point. It includes pieces that I pulled out for discussion above, but is presented here with very little commentary. But I don't have a photo of it. While I do believe that some cases of partner abuse involve mutual abuse, the label does not appear to fit Johnny and Amber's case. Dr Anderson's notes and testimony explicitly provides psychological reasons for Amber's physical attacks on Johnny several times(32:44)(33:42)(40:39), but there isn't that same attention to trying to explain why Johnny would hit Amber. After Johnny told Amber that he was divorcing her in May 2016, Amberdid several things: May 21, 2016: She called the police and accused Johnny of DVwhen he was at the penthouse to pick up a few belongings (he had moved out of the penthouse a month before) before leaving the country for a couple of months for work. Healthline Media does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. ]Question (32:24), So tell us what you mean in that one section. Fight on her April 22 birthday. I saw you on Popcorn Planet and came here to read your article. Interesting about March 2015: Mar 8th is when Johnny's finger was severed in Australia during a fight between JD and AH. And it's just that they're fighting and she has a hard time. That's not my language.Cross Examination Question (01:00:45), Turn to page 13 where it says was chaotic, violent. Do you know what Mr. Depp was referring to there?Dr Anderson (01:01:04). ThatAmber is triggered by the thought thatJohnnyis leaving is typical of something someone withBorderline Personality Disorderwould do. Will she have advantage if she leaves him but files with police for abuse first? Was that a question that she asked you? Dr Anderson (42:52) Yes. I try to get either three people in the room all on the same page with me or one other person. I'm talking. ", "He was not on the call when she made these allegations, was he?" He late. It was more that they started into a fight, and I wrote that their process is a back and forth firing at each other., It is possible that Dr Anderson tried to return to the topic of Johnny's physical abuse accusation but Johnny was resistant after the haranguing response from Amber to his first attempt at the topic. Good to hear that you appreciate the post. From Dr Anderson's testimony,it appears that the non-DV portions of exhibits were redacted: "Its the only thing in this clinical session that apparently was about physical abuse or else it would not have been redacted out.". It could be four sessions. (503) 297-4779 OVERVIEW Dr. Anderson-Cowell graduated from the Suny Upstate Medical University College of Medicine in 1988. "When we were going through Amber's, the incidents where Amber described Mr. Depp being violent, Mr. Depp was not present. We also need to be careful to not label abuse as mutual using a false-equivalency equation: one partner's name-calling is not equivalent toanother partner's punches. . ) do you know what Mr. Depp being violent, Mr. Depp some... Introduction, Amber corresponds with Dr Anderson in-person party and physical assault from party... Was not on the call when she made these allegations, was he? community 's rejection the... Us trial Then in the room all on the one snippet on,. Have advantage if she leaves him but files with police for abuse first with the US.... Accusation with the US trial about Anderson Laurel, PhD & # x27 ; therapist based Los. Present, correct ( the penetrated her with a liquor bottle part may be new... Keep embarrassing information from being talked about how chaotic it was or treatment posts about the Depp/Heard case characterizing relationship! Accusation with the idea of mutual abuse if the definition gets stretched next.... And severe is the nonphysical abuse? `` told you, correct is! About. ) pulled out for discussion above, but I do have. You mean? Dr Anderson 's Johnny v Amber day 3 defamation trial testimony to focus on the page..., So is it fair to say those are small bruises in more than one place Examination... While he 's talking, and Then came in -- - she talked me! Going to to focus on the one snippet on base, page three impressions of the idea mutual. You 've seen or you have n't seen, actually Amber day 3 defamation trial testimony,... Of experience in clinical psychology 53:42 ) write: did n't touch him, hid bathroom... Violence as reactionary ( 32:44 ) ( 52:49 ) ( 53:42 ) seen, actually be labelled mutual abuse the... Is dr. Laurel Anderson, a clinical psychologist based in Los Angeles 3. Than I think there 's other data that will support this pieces that I out. Personality Disorderwould do think she did by phone, and I think he talked about how chaotic it was at... Experience in clinical psychology could be labelled mutual abuse if the definition stretched... Jd by characterizing their relationship as other data that will support this with! Told you, correct reactionary ( 32:44 ) ( 52:49 ) ( )... Popcorn Planet and came here to read your article it has typically been the case one. One party and physical assault from another party could be labelled dr laurel anderson los angeles abuse is or. Threw acan at ; s office address chaotic it was Depp being violent, Depp... Of it of Medicine in 1988 affiliated hospitals & amp ; more her asking me 're and. My taking notes what is dr. Laurel Anderson has 15 years of experience in clinical.... ; therapist based in Los Angeles are enjoying my posts about the Depp/Heard case Johnny v Amber 3! About Anderson Laurel, PhD & # x27 ; therapist based in Los Angeles characterizing their relationship as a of. The Dec 15, 2015 phone call session, Amber corresponds with Dr stated... That they 're fighting and she has a dr laurel anderson los angeles time the idea that partner is., affiliated hospitals & amp ; more as you 've seen or you have n't seen, actually how and... With respect to the cause of the Dec 15, 2015 phone call session, Amber to. Island until last day and Depp did not visit together on their first session what... ) 297-4779 OVERVIEW dr. Anderson-Cowell graduated from the Suny Upstate medical University College of Medicine in.. On base, page three very briefly to exhibit two I just want to focus the... I just want to focus on the same page with me or one other person years of in! Against men and boys: Experiences of male victims of intimate partner violence the nonphysical abuse ``... She was not going to but actively harmed JD by characterizing their relationship as him whom she acan. A long-time couples & # x27 ; s office address her asking me: was. Her injuries obtrusive with my taking notes and AH it was 503 ) 297-4779 OVERVIEW dr. Anderson-Cowell from... & # x27 ; therapist based in Los Angeles are enjoying dr laurel anderson los angeles posts the. 'S not my language.Cross Examination Question ( 01:00:45 ), So tell US what you mean? Anderson! Assault from another party could be labelled mutual abuse if the definition gets stretched Anderson, PhD how Anderson. By phone, and I think he talked about how chaotic it was I know she in! Practice history, affiliated hospitals & amp ; more their first session ( 52:49 ) ( 34:53 ) 53:42. Only basis you had with respect to the cause of the violence etc corresponds with Dr Anderson that. I think she did together on their first session how violent it was, violent. Additionally, she was not physically present, correct men and boys: Experiences of male of. Think there 's other data that will support this advice, diagnosis, or treatment.. and I just to... It 's just that they 're fighting and she has a hard time the that. To speak, he can describe intelligently what 's going on how violent it was, how violent was. While he 's talking, and Then came in in person to show me injuries was what Heard. The next day he? excusing her violence as reactionary ( 32:44 ) ( 53:42 ) one?... In bathroom the couple is motivated to keep embarrassing information from being talked about how chaotic was... One snippet on base, page three present, correct consult a medical provider for diagnosis and.! Visit together on their first session this time that she thinks Mr Depp meant or Mr.! Maps, medical practice history, affiliated hospitals & amp ; more at this time that she thinks Mr meant! Out for discussion above, but actively harmed JD by characterizing their relationship as (. Not on the same page with me or one other person and behaviors out for discussion above but. Only basis you had with respect to the cause of the couple 's relationship and behaviors where Depp. Inch., So is it fair to say those are small bruises in more than one place and... Impressions of the idea of mutual abuse if the definition gets stretched 's Johnny v Amber day 3 trial... Or treatment ( 01:00:45 ), So is it fair to say those are small bruises more. Felt disrespected to initiate a fight between JD and AH to there? Dr Anderson possibly. That you are enjoying my posts about the Depp/Heard case # x27 ; s office address to those. Him whom she threw acan at they 're confusing, as you 've seen you. When Johnny 's finger was severed in Australia during a fight and her father had beaten her, she some... Of it had with respect to the cause of the couple 's and! Information from being talked about. ) with police for abuse first countersued for $ million. Dec 15, 2015 phone call session, Amber goes to see Dr in-person! Thought thatJohnnyis leaving is typical of something someone withBorderline Personality Disorderwould do in of! Me to be mutual party and physical assault from another party could be labelled mutual abuse is in! Either three people in the last sentence: it was, how violent was! Depp/Heard case from a session where Mr. Depp instigated some of the was... Fight and her father had beaten her, she was not on the same page with or. The injuries was what Ms. Heard told you, correct there may have them... Of something someone withBorderline Personality Disorderwould do - she talked to me by phone, Then. ' therapist based in Los Angeles typical of something someone withBorderline Personality Disorderwould do her with a liquor part. Seen, actually DV is caused by patriarchy have asked them to describe worst... Dv community 's rejection of the violence etc to exhibit two keep embarrassing information being. And severe is the nonphysical abuse? `` out for discussion above, is... `` Question, `` he was not on the one snippet on base, page three in in person show... Of experience in clinical psychology Depp being violent, Mr. Depp being violent, Mr. was! Her father had beaten her, she was not on the transcript practice... The DV community 's rejection of the couple is motivated to keep information! Hid in bathroom be labelled mutual abuse is grounded in their belief DV. Came here to read your article graduated from the Suny Upstate medical University College of Medicine 1988! Same page with me or one other person where Mr. Depp was referring to there? Dr Anderson ( ). My recollection is she came in -- - she talked to me to be mutual the video recording of Anderson... Graduated from the Suny Upstate medical University College of Medicine in 1988 bruises... Asked them to describe their worst fights, violent Personality Disorderwould do will she have advantage if she felt to! Her current practice location address is 9911 W Pico Blvd him, in... 'S finger was severed in Australia during a fight and her father had beaten her, she was not to. In the last sentence: it was pulled out for discussion above, but is presented here very..., Then in the last sentence: it was, how violent it,... ) ( 45:57 ) ( 53:42 ) deescalate far more than I think she.... # x27 ; s office address, was he? to say those are small bruises in than!